Indian Railways eyes private Steel suppliers

Recently, a Parliamentary Panel observed that the state-owned steel giant ‘SAIL’ may post a net loss of Rs.4,211 in the next fiscal and asked the company to make sincere efforts to restore its “the dwindling fortune” to “past glory”.

NEW DELHI: Indian Railways is considering ending state-owned Steel Authority of India Ltd’s (SAIL) virtual monopoly on supplying steel for standard rail tracks, opening up annual purchases worth up to $700 million to the private sector, people close to the matter told Reuters.

The vast state rail operator is undergoing a $130 billion, five-year overhaul to modernise the world’s fourth-largest network, which is blighted by ageing track and saturated capacity.

The government has also launched a $15 billion fund to improve rail safety. Train accidents due to track defects have risen 25 percent in the last two years, the railway ministry told parliament last week.

In the current fiscal year, SAIL is set to fall around 250,000 tonnes of rails short of its 850,000 tonne target, according to the company’s data – its eighth shortfall in 10 years, and its biggest.

SAIL executives said a sudden jump in demand for steel – up 45 percent since 2015 – to replace old tracks and lay new ones meant it was struggling to meet production targets. The company said the launch this year of a long-delayed new rolling mill at its main plant at Bhilai, in eastern India, would boost its capacity by around 100,000 tonnes.

Losing even a small part of its sales to the railways – its top customer – would be a blow to SAIL, which has lost money in seven straight quarters.

“SAIL’s performance has been very poor and given that we have a MoU (Memorandum of Understanding), any failure will not be appreciated,” a government official said, quoting from a Jan. 11 letter from the railways to the steel ministry that oversees SAIL, threatening to sever a deal to buy rails almost exclusively from the company.

Two other government officials confirmed the railways’ threat. All three officials declined to be identified because of the sensitivity of the matter.

The rails shortfall has slowed Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s plans to revamp the network, and highlights how his infrastructure investment drive is forcing government units to get tough on suppliers.

The biggest likely winner from opening up to private suppliers is Jindal Steel and Power Ltd, which has already exported rails to Iran and has tried for years to muscle in on SAIL’s business.

Jindal Steel wrote to Indian Railways on March 6, offering to step in, according to a letter reviewed by Reuters. A spokesman for Jindal Steel said the firm was keen to help the railways with steel for its modernisation.


The railways are already looking at bringing in alternative suppliers gradually by issuing new tenders for rails.

“Even after giving sufficient time to SAIL if the shortfall continues, the ministry of railways may explore the possibility of outsourcing some supplies,” Indian Railways spokesman Anil Kumar Saxena said.

Modi has made increased infrastructure spending a key part of his economic plans since coming to power in 2014. State expenditure on roads and rails is at a record high.

“We need more steel because we are increasing laying of lines, gauge conversion and completing a backlog of work,” said A.K. Mittal, the railways’ board member in charge of track procurement. “We have seen a shortfall in the last year because of some issues at Bhilai. The existing rolling machine is an old one.”

Two steel ministry officials said SAIL has offered to import 150,000-200,000 tonnes of rails to fill this year’s shortfall. But ministry officials had noted there was nothing to stop the railways themselves importing, and cutting out SAIL, one of the two officials said.

A Parliamentary Panel recently said that the state-owned SAIL may post a net loss of Rs 4,211 in the next fiscal and asked the company to make sincere efforts to restore its “the dwindling fortune” to “past glory”. “However, the Committee note that for the year 2017-18, income of SAIL is targetted at Rs 64,155 crore but still, SAIL is likely to post a net loss of Rs 4,211 crore during 2017-18,” Standing Committee on Coal and Steel said in its latest report tabled in Parliament.

It noted with distress that income of SAIL has declined steadily during the last three years on account of sluggish market conditions. The income of the company which was Rs 53,470 crore in 2014-15 declined to Rs 43,934 crore in 2015-16 and to Rs 22,292 crore during 2016-17 (up to September, 2016).

“The Committee observed that net sales of the company at Rs 31,330 crore are up by 14.9 per cent,” the report said.

As regards physical performance parameters, the committee expressed its satisfaction at 16 per cent growth in saleable steel production at 10.2 MT, 14.7 per cent in value added production at 4.3 MT and 16 per cent growth in saleable steel sales at 9.7 MT, it said.

“The Committee while appreciating these positive trends in physical and financial performance of SAIL, desire that earnest efforts be continued to bring back the dwindling fortunes of the company to its past glory,” it said.